How to Handle a Police Interrogation

A police interrogation is a questioning process by law enforcement officers to gather information about a crime or suspect. It can be formal or informal. It can occur anywhere: an interrogation room at a police station, inside a patrol vehicle, at the scene of an alleged crime, roadside during a traffic stop, at your residence or place of employment, on the sidewalk of a public street, in a jail cell, or anywhere else.

The person being questioned may or may not be in custody and may or may not be in handcuffs. The questioning may or may not be video or audio recorded, as there is no law that requires police questioning to be recorded. But if you are or could be a suspect, knowing how to handle a police interrogation properly is necessary for protecting your rights and avoiding self-incrimination.

Read on to learn about your constitutional rights during interrogation, common police tactics, and the steps you should take if you find yourself in this situation.

Your Rights During a Police Interrogation

As a suspect in a criminal investigation, you have two fundamental rights that law enforcement must respect at all times during questioning, if you are in custody:

If you are in custody, law enforcement must advise you of the following rights before they can legally question you:

  • You have the right to remain silent.
  • Anything you say can and will be used against you in court.
  • You have the right to an attorney.
  • Legal counsel will be provided if you cannot afford an attorney.

These rights are based on the famous Supreme Court case Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966), and are now known simply as the Miranda rights. Invoking these constitutional rights during an interrogation can be critical to protecting your freedom later.

Please note, however, that law enforcement does NOT have to read the Miranda rights if (1) you are not in custody or (2) they are not questioning you. In other words, Miranda applies only to custodial interrogations. Therefore, a common police tactic is to question a suspect before taking him or her into custody without reading Miranda, and if the suspect answers the questions, the answers are admissible at trial.

Likewise, police do not have to read Miranda rights at the moment of arrest – that’s the type of thing that happens in movies and television, but not in real life. In the real world, police almost never read Miranda rights at the moment of arrest. The rule is that police must read Miranda rights before in-custody questioning begins. The amount of time between arrest and the reading of Miranda rights varies. And if law enforcement never questions the suspect while in custody, they may never read the Miranda rights.

Another common misconception is what happens when there is a Miranda violation. Often, people think that if law enforcement fails to read Miranda rights, then the entire case can be thrown out, but that is not true. Miranda is a rule of evidence. In order for the prosecution to introduce a defendant’s statements into evidence at trial, if those statements were made in response to in-custody police questioning, law enforcement must have read the suspect his or her Miranda rights beforehand. If law enforcement failed to do so, the statements are not admissible at trial. But the case can still be prosecuted on the basis of other evidence.

Common Police Interrogation Tactics

Law enforcement sometimes employs corrosive tactics to elicit information from suspects during an interrogation.

Some standard techniques include:

  • Good Cop, Bad Cop: One officer may act friendly and understanding, while another takes a more aggressive approach to pressure you into talking.
  • Minimization: Officers may downplay the severity of the crime to make you feel more comfortable about confessing.
  • Maximization: Interrogators might exaggerate their evidence against you to make it seem like confessing is your best option.
  • Lying About Evidence: Police may claim to have evidence or witnesses that don’t exist to trick you into confessing. Yes, in the American criminal justice system, police can lie to suspects – and they do it all the time.
  • Promising Not To File Charges or To “Make It All Go Away”: Police will implore suspects to “work with them” and “help me help you.” They will suggest, imply, or even outright promise not to file charges or to “make it all go away” if the suspect just cooperates or “plays ball.” But law enforcement does not have the authority to reach binding agreements with suspects – only prosecutors and criminal defense attorneys do that. It is very common for police to promise a suspect that they won’t file a case against them in exchange for a confession; the suspect confesses, and then later, the case is issued. The suspect-now-defendant will claim that he or she had a deal with the police, but no such “deal” is enforceable.

Be aware of these strategies, and remember that you can remain silent and request an attorney, regardless of what the officers say.

The Risks of Talking to Police Without a Lawyer

Anything you say during an interrogation can be used as evidence against you in court. Even if you’re innocent, your statements could be taken out of context or misinterpreted, leading to self-incrimination.

False confessions are more common than many people realize, often resulting from high-pressure interrogation tactics or a suspect’s mental or emotional vulnerability.

And there is NO upside to answering law enforcement’s questions. Even if the suspect answers all questions truthfully, completely, accurately, and in a manner that is consistent with innocence, it won’t help. The reason is that if the statements are not incriminating, the prosecution will not introduce them at trial.

And, under the rules of evidence, the defendant cannot introduce his own out-of-court statements as evidence because such statements are hearsay. So, the suspect’s answers are admitted into evidence at trial if and only if the answers are incriminating. If the answers are exculpatory, the jury never hears them.

Can Police Bring You in for Questioning Without a Warrant?

The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects against unreasonable searches and seizures by the government. This means law enforcement generally needs a warrant issued by a judge before arresting or detaining someone, with some exceptions.

However, the short answer is yes: police can temporarily arrest a suspect without a warrant and attempt to question them in certain situations. Under Section 544.170 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, law enforcement may detain a person for up to 24 hours without a warrant “for any alleged breach of the peace or other criminal offense, or on suspicion thereof.”

It is common for law enforcement agencies in Missouri to arrest someone, book them at the police station, and attempt to question them – all without a warrant – pursuant to this statute.

Trick Questions Cops Ask During Police Interrogation

Police interrogations are designed to obtain confessions and information from suspects. One technique officers often use is asking seemingly harmless or misleading questions intended to catch you off guard or trip you up. Being aware of some common trick questions can help you avoid falling into these traps during an interrogation.

  • “Do you know why I pulled you over/why you’re here?” They are fishing to see if you’ll admit to something unprompted. It’s safer to respond, “No, why am I here?”
  • “Where are you coming from/going?” This attempts to get you revealing travel details that could raise suspicions or contradictions.
  • “If your friend said you did X, would they be lying?” This imaginary scenario tries to get you to discuss hypothetical situations that can be used against you.
  • “Why would they say you did X?” Again, this is a fishing question, and the police may be lying to you about what someone else said.
  • “Can I search your house/car, etc?” You have the right to refuse consent for searches without a warrant in most situations.

When asked leading or loaded questions during interrogations, remember you have the right to remain silent. Don’t feel pressured to respond or get drawn into a discussion over misleading hypotheticals. Maintaining your right against self-incrimination is legally protected.

What Should You Do if the Police Interrogate You?

There’s really only one word you need to remember: LAWYER. If the police want to question you, just say the word LAWYER. Under Miranda v. Arizona, all questioning is required to stop when the subject asks for an attorney. So the best advice is to keep it simple and say the word LAWYER.

Other tips include:

  1. Stay calm and polite: Getting angry or confrontational will only worsen the situation.
  2. Invoke your right to remain silent: Clearly state that you wish to remain silent and do not want to answer any questions.
  3. Request a lawyer: Tell the officers you want to speak with an attorney and that you will only answer questions once your lawyer is present.
  4. Do not lie or provide false information: Lying to the police can lead to additional charges and damage your credibility.

When invoking your rights during an interrogation, use unambiguous language to assert your rights during a police interrogation.

Say something like, “I wish to invoke my right to remain silent,” or “I want to speak with a lawyer before answering any questions, please.” Be firm and consistent in your request, and only engage in further conversation once your attorney arrives. Or just say the word LAWYER – over and over, if necessary.

Remember, the police cannot punish you for asserting your constitutional rights. The interrogation should stop once you remain silent and request an attorney.

Law enforcement may still detain you if they have probable cause to believe you committed a crime, but they cannot continue questioning you without your criminal defense attorney present.

How Our Criminal Defense Attorneys Protect Your Rights

A seasoned criminal defense law firm protects your rights and interests during a police questioning by:

  • Advising you on what not to say
  • Ensuring that the police follow proper procedures and do not violate your rights.
  • Intervening to prevent police interrogation
  • Providing valuable legal knowledge and experience to guide you through the process.

With a criminal defense attorney by your side, you can get through police questioning with confidence, knowing that your rights are protected. Don’t face interrogation alone – let an experienced legal professional level the playing field and ensure that justice is served.

Protect Your Rights During Police Questioning – Contact Rose Legal Services Now

Knowing how to handle a police interrogation is necessary for protecting your rights and avoiding self-incrimination. When you understand your rights, recognize common police tactics, and take the appropriate steps during questioning, you minimize the risks associated with an interrogation.

Most importantly, remember to invoke your right to remain silent and request a lawyer before answering any questions.

Contact Rose Legal Services today to schedule a consultation to get the guidance, support, and representation you need during a police interrogation.

Author Bio

Scott Rose, an experienced criminal defense lawyer and founder of Rose Legal Services, has been practicing law for over 20 years. He is dedicated to representing clients facing criminal charges and providing legal representation on various cases, including DWI, misdemeanor, and felony cases.

After graduating from the University of Virginia School of Law, he gained valuable experience working for a United States Senator and as a Judicial Law Clerk for the Chief Judge of a United States District Court. Throughout his legal career, W. Scott Rose has committed to providing high-quality legal representation to his clients, earning him a spot in the National Top 100 Trial Lawyers.

LinkedIn | State Bar Association | Avvo | Google

Contact us icon